Should our inspection use AQL 2.5 or 4.0 for major defects on knitwear?

Share

Flat illustration of an inspection checklist, a magnifying glass over stitches and a measuring tape

Should our inspection use AQL 2.5 or 4.0 for major defects on knitwear?

An AQL is a quality level the sampling plan is built around, not a defect allowance. Choose by defect class, and define the defects before choosing the numbers.

Defects & QC DiagnosisKnitwear Talk3 min readKnitwear Base Editorial Team
Flat illustration of an inspection checklist, a magnifying glass over stitches and a measuring tape
Buyer question

Our inspection agent proposed AQL 2.5 for major defects and 4.0 for minor defects. The factory wants 4.0 for both. We do not really know what the numbers mean in practice. How should we decide?

Main answer
Knitwear Base Editorial Team
Main answer

In sampling plans such as ISO 2859-1, the acceptance quality limit, or AQL, is the quality level the plan is designed around for a series of lots. Together with the lot size and the inspection level, it determines the sample size and how many defective units are allowed in the sample before the lot is rejected. A lower AQL number means a stricter plan. It does not mean the lot may contain exactly that percentage of defects; it describes how the sampling plan is likely to treat lots of different quality.

Define the defect classes first

The AQL only works if everyone agrees what counts as critical, major and minor. A critical defect could make the product unsafe or illegal to sell, such as a broken needle or a drawstring on a small child's hood. A major defect would likely lead to a return, such as a hole, a wrong size or a stain on the front. A minor defect is a small departure that most customers would not return the item for. Write a defect list with examples for your products and attach it to the inspection booking.

Choosing the levels

Many buyers allow no critical defects at all, use a stricter AQL for major defects than for minor ones, and adjust based on product value and the risk of returns. A premium line or a first order with a new factory may justify a stricter major level. Whatever you choose, use the same levels across inspections so results can be compared.

Name the edition and inspection level

ISO 2859-1 was revised in 2026, so state the edition in the purchase order. Also state the inspection level, since it changes the sample size. General inspection level II is a common default in sampling tables.

Add measured checks

AQL sampling covers defects found by visual and functional checks. Measurements such as shrinkage after a named wash procedure such as ISO 6330, or fabric weight under ASTM D3776, need their own sampling rules and pass limits.

Review results over several orders. If one defect type keeps appearing, fix it at source rather than relying on the AQL to catch it.

Sources and further reading

Standards and rules are summarised from their published scope or official guidance. Use the current edition and confirm requirements for your market.

Three perspectives on this question

Knitwear Base Editorial Team
Purchasing perspective

I'd put the AQL levels, inspection level, ISO 2859-1 edition and defect list in the purchase order, so the factory agrees to them before production.

Knitwear Base Editorial Team
Merchandising perspective

I'd help write the defect list with real examples from past returns, so major defects reflect what customers actually send back.

Knitwear Base Editorial Team
QC perspective

We'd report defects by class and type for every lot. The type breakdown is more useful for improving the factory than the pass or fail result alone.

Working on a similar program?Send your tech pack, fabric references and test requirements. We reply with a quote and the questions we need answered.

Contact Knitwear Base

Related products

Recycled Yoga Fabrics: Claims, Documentation and Reorder Control

Buying a recycled yoga fabric involves two approvals: evidence for the material claim and evidence that the fabric works in the intended garment. A chain-of-custody document does not establish opacity, recovery or waistband behavior. A successful fit sample does not establish recycled content. Keep the records linked by article and lot, then review both when

Read More »

Brushed Yoga Fabrics: Pilling, Abrasion and Hand-Feel Retention

A brushed yoga fabric may offer a soft surface that buyers and customers notice immediately. That first impression should be compared with how the surface behaves after friction and care. Pilling, abrasion damage, shedding and loss of hand feel are related concerns, but they are not the same property. This guide focuses on brushed studio

Read More »

Matching Yoga Sets: Shade Approval Across Different Fabrics

Matching a yoga top and legging is a paired approval, especially when the pieces use different fabrics. Two fabrics can each sit close to a shared color standard yet look noticeably different beside one another. Surface, structure, finish and stretch all influence the comparison. Keep a master color target, but approve the finished pair as

Read More »
Scroll to Top
Leave Your Message