A container of our tees arrived water damaged. Who was supposed to insure it under FOB or CIF?
Under FOB neither side has to insure. Under CIF and CIP the seller must buy a minimum level of cover. Arrange your own cargo policy so the cover matches the risk and the contract.

Our last sea shipment of tees arrived with wet cartons. The supplier says the risk was ours after loading and the freight forwarder says the carrier’s liability is limited. Nobody had insurance. What did the terms say, and how do we avoid this?
Main answer
Under Incoterms 2020, the rule you chose decides who must buy cargo insurance, if anyone. Many buyers assume the supplier or the carrier covers damage in transit, but under common terms such as FOB that is not the case. This is general guidance on the ICC rules, not legal advice, so check your own contract and policy.
FOB
Under FOB the seller delivers when the goods are placed on board the vessel at the named port. After that, the risk of loss or damage passes to the buyer. The rules do not require either party to buy insurance, though the buyer may choose to. If your contract is FOB and nobody bought cover, the loss from damage at sea falls on the buyer.
CIF and CIP
Under CIF, the seller must obtain cargo insurance, at a minimum level of cover under the Institute Cargo Clauses (C), covering at least 110% of the contract price to the named destination port. Under CIP the seller must obtain cover at the higher Institute Cargo Clauses (A) level, also at least 110% of the price. In both cases the seller buys the policy for the buyer’s benefit, while the risk passes to the buyer earlier in the journey, so check that the cover starts where your risk starts. A minimum cover may not include the damage you worry about, such as water damage, so read what is included.
Carrier liability is not insurance
A carrier’s liability for cargo is limited by the contract of carriage and by law and is often much lower than the value of the goods. It also depends on proving the carrier’s fault. Cargo insurance responds to defined risks regardless of the carrier’s liability. Treat the two as separate.
What to do
Ask your forwarder or broker for a cargo policy for each shipment or an annual policy, with an agreed value, the right clause level for your goods, and cover from the factory to your warehouse if possible. Check how to report damage: photograph cartons, note damage on delivery documents and inform the insurer promptly. Keep packing lists, the invoice and the bill of lading.
Packing for wet risk
Ask the factory to pack tees in sealed poly bags inside strong cartons, and consider desiccant or container liners for long voyages.
Sources and further reading
- ICC — Incoterms® 2020 rules
- ICC Digital Library — FOB explanatory notes (Incoterms® 2020)
- ICC Digital Library — Incoterms® 2020 rules for any mode of transport (incl. CIP)
Standards and rules are summarised from their published scope or official guidance. Use the current edition and confirm requirements for your market.
Three perspectives on this question
Purchasing perspective
I'd get a cargo policy quote with every FOB quote and write the insurance responsibility into the order, so it is never assumed.
Merchandising perspective
A wet shipment is a missed season, so the cost of cover is small next to the lost sales.
QC perspective
We'd photograph every damaged carton at the destination before opening it and keep the photos with the claim documents.
Working on a similar program?Send your tech pack, fabric references and test requirements. We reply with a quote and the questions we need answered.
Contact Knitwear BaseRelated products
Related articles
- Clothing Manufacturer for Startups: How Buyers Verify Capability Before Sampling
- Custom Apparel Manufacturer: Tech Pack Inputs Required Before a Quote Is Valid
- Clothing Manufacturer China: A Capability Map by Product Category, Not Another Evaluation Checklist
- Shipping Clothes From China: Freight Modes, Incoterms and Landed Cost
- How to Manufacture Clothing in China: The Operational Sequence From Brief to Shipment
- Eco Friendly Clothing Materials: Choosing by Application, Not by Ranking
- Custom Hoodie Manufacturer: What to Confirm Before You Send a Tech Pack
- Custom T Shirt Manufacturer: What to Confirm Before You Send a Tech Pack
- Jockstrap Manufacturer: How Buyers Verify Capability Before Sampling
- Boxer Briefs Manufacturer: How Buyers Verify Capability Before Sampling

